It was less than 20 years ago that the power brokers in college football were steadfastly against a playoff to determine one true champion. Funny how opinions change when the almighty dollar is brought into play.
Monday’s announcement that the playoff is expanding to 24 teams in 2027 isn’t a bad idea on its own, but the problem is which teams have easier paths, while others have more difficult paths, assuming they exist at all. If the whole purpose is for the rich to get richer, that will continue to draw fans away from the sport.
And leave it to CFP executive director Rich Clark to have this response to fan opinion: “….ultimately, we just need to make a spectacular playoff. The CFP has a responsibility to our fans. They’re the lifeblood of college football, and we [owe] it to them to make this great, and that really is our intent. We appreciate our fans. We did take into account their sentiment, and that was rolled into this decision, but we decided to move forward with it.”
If the statement was any more blatant, Clark would’ve flat out said that the Alabamas, Notre Dames, and Ohio States are set for life, or at least until the power brokers invent some other asinine idea. But what about the Boise States?
This problem has dated back to the Bowl Alliance and Bowl Championship Series. Who remembers the 2009 season, when TCU and Boise State were both undefeated, yet were paired against each other in what some dubbed the “Kids’ Table Bowl?”
But instead of learning from mistakes, or at the very least reserving spots in the 24-team field for all conference champions, the committee decided to leave only the five reserved spots, with only one Group of 6 spot guaranteed, and best of luck to that team being deemed worthy enough of a first-round bye.
Even among the power conference teams, there are tiers of favoritism. Take Wake Forest, currently ranked #13 at 8-1, with their only loss to #5 Miami. If the Demon Deacons do make it to the ACC Championship Game, that alone should be enough to put them in this year’s playoff. If they can at least push Miami to the brink, they’ll be a shoo-in. But if the committee is forced to pick between Wake or a team from the Big Ten or SEC, it doesn’t take a Nobel laureate to figure out who wins that debate most of the time.
College football has made some improvements bringing the playoff into existence, but its tendencies to be just a new format of establishing the same order have fans at a crossroads. As long as the status quo stays, its popularity will decrease, and by the time a rational solution is finally introduced, it could be too late.